Agenda item
Consider request to review refusal in respect of erection of 4 No. dwellinghouses on Land West of Greenburn Cottage, Auchencrow - 23/00004/RREF
Copies of the following papers attached:-
Minutes:
CONTINUATION OF review of 23/00004/RREF
5.1 With reference to paragraph 3 of the Minute of 20 March 2023, there had been circulated copies of a request from W A Mole & Son, c/o Cockburn’s Consultants. 1A Belford Park, Edinburgh to review the decision to refuse the planning application for the erection of 4 No. dwellinghouses on Land West of Greenburn Cottage, Auchencrow. The supporting papers included the written submissions from the Planning Officer and Applicant in respect of NPF4; Notice of Review (including the Decision Notice and Officer’s Report); Additional Information and Consultation Replies and list of policies.
5.2 Members noted that Auchencrow was not a recognised settlement within the Local Plan, therefore the key issues were compliance with LDP Policy HD2 on housing in the countryside, PMD2 on visual impacts and road safety and SPGs on housing in the countryside and placemaking and design. The Appointed Officer and the applicants were in agreement that there was an established building group at Auchencrow and that there was numerical capacity within the building group for an additional four houses under the terms of Policy HD2. There was concern with regard to loss of prime agricultural land and the Members requested that the application be continued to allow for a site visit and for the site to be marked out for their inspection to assist with their understanding of its relationship with the building group.
.
DECISION
AGREED that:-
(a) the request for review had been competently made in terms of Section 43A of the Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997;
(b) the review could not be considered without the need for further procedure in the form of a site visit;
(c) the proposed site be marked out in order that they could visualise the amount of agricultural land to be used; and
(d) consideration of the review be continued to a future meeting on a date to be confirmed.
Supporting documents:
- Item 7(a) - PLANNING_OFFICERS_RESPONSE__IMPACTS -NPF4, item 6. PDF 375 KB
- Item 7(a) - Appl response to Officers statement NPF4, item 6. PDF 120 KB
- NOR 1 - NOTICE_OF_REVIEW_FORM-3734971, item 6. PDF 83 KB
- NOR 2 - REVIEW_SUMMARY_OF_DOCUMENTS, item 6. PDF 37 KB
- NOR 3 - GROUNDS_OF_APPEAL_STATEMENT-3734969, item 6. PDF 784 KB
- NOR 4 - OFFICERS_REPORT_OF_HANDLING-3734972, item 6. PDF 125 KB
- NOR 5 - PLANNING_APPLICATION_FORM-3734974, item 6. PDF 93 KB
- NOR 6 - DECISION_NOTICE-3734967, item 6. PDF 69 KB
- NOR 7 - EXISTING_SITE_PLAN-3734968, item 6. PDF 532 KB
- NOR 8 - LOCATION_PLAN-3734970, item 6. PDF 260 KB
- NOR 9 - ORIGINAL_SUPPORTING_STATEMENT-3734973, item 6. PDF 916 KB
- NOR 10 - PROPOSED_SITE_PLAN-3734975, item 6. PDF 677 KB
- Item 7(c) -16_00531_FUL_-_DECISION_NOTICE-3770228, item 6. PDF 208 KB
- Item 7(c) -15_00424_FUL_-_DECISION_NOTICE-3770221, item 6. PDF 177 KB
- Item 7(c) - 15_00424_FUL_-_REPORT_OF_HANDLING, item 6. PDF 25 KB
- Item 7(c) -10_00786_FUL_-_DECISION_NOTICE, item 6. PDF 480 KB
- Item 7(c) - 05_02351_FUL_-_DECISION_NOTICE, item 6. PDF 86 KB
- Item 7(c) - 05_02351_FUL_-_REPORT_OF_HANDLING, item 6. PDF 42 KB
- Item 7(d) - 2201666_PPP_-_CONSULTATION_REPLIES, item 6. PDF 480 KB
- Item 7 (e) - May 2023 LRB Policies, item 6. PDF 91 KB