Agenda item
Continuation: Consider request for review of refusal of application for Part Change of Use of ground floor to class 10 and alterations to form additional office space from attic floor at 3 Rowan Court Suite, 3 Cavalry Park, Peebles - 21/00486/FUL and 21/00015/RREF
Copies of the following papers attached:-
Minutes:
CONTINUATION OF REVIEW 21/00486/FUL
With reference to paragraph 5 of the Minute of 16 August 2021, there had been re-circulated copies of the request from Mr S Lamb, 3 Rowan Court, Cavalry Park, Peebles to review the decision to refuse the planning application for the Change of Use of part of the ground floor to Class10 – Non-residential institutions and the conversion of the loft to accommodate additional office space, Class 4 – Business. The supporting papers included the Notice of Review; Decision Notice; Officer’s Report; papers referred to in the Officer’s Report; Consultations and a list of policies. Also circulated were copies of further information in the form of DDL Care Hub Ltd – Business Plan and Cavalry Park – List of Companies; and responses requested by the Local Review Body to the additional information from the Council’s Planning Officers and Chief Social Work Officer with a further response to those submissions from the applicant. . Following consideration of all relevant information, the Local Review Body concluded that the development was consistent with Policies ED1 and PMD3 of the Local Development Plan. The development was considered to be a complimentary use within Cavalry Park, created replacement Class 4 use on the first floor and offered significant community benefits that outweighed the need to retain Class 4 use on the ground floor. Consequently, the application was approved.
DECISION
AGREED that:-
(a) the request for review had been competently made in terms of Section 43A of the Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997;
(b) the review could be considered without the need for any further procedure on the basis of the papers submitted and the comments from the Officers on new information;
(c) the proposal would be consistent with policies ED1 and PMD3 of the Local Development Plan; and
(c) the officer’s decision to refuse the application be reversed and planning permission be granted, subject to conditions for the reasons detailed in Appendix II to this Minute.
Supporting documents:
- LRB decision notice - Cavalry Park, item 2. PDF 324 KB
- Item 5(a) - 21_00015_RREF-SOCIAL_WORKS_RESPONSE_TO_LRB_QUEST, item 2. PDF 98 KB
- Item No. 5(a) - 21_00015_RREF-OFF_RESPONSE_TO_LRB_QUEST-, item 2. PDF 63 KB
- Item No. 5(a) - 21_00015_RREF-APPLINT_RESPONSE_TO_DDL_CA, item 2. PDF 332 KB
- Item No.5(a) - 21_00015_RREF-LETTR_OF_SUPP-DAVIDMUNDELL, item 2. PDF 418 KB
- Item No. 5(a) - 21_00015_RREF-PEEBLES_COMMUNITY-3540947, item 2. PDF 525 KB
- Item No. 5(a) - 21_00015_RREF-HSCP_E-MAIL_TO_DDL-3540945, item 2. PDF 142 KB
- Item No. 5(a) -21_00015_RREF-LETTERS-3540944, item 2. PDF 4 MB
- NOR 1 - APPLICATION_PDF-3504404, item 2. PDF 2 MB
- NOR 2 - SCHEDULE_OF_SUBMISSION_DOCUMENTS-3502015, item 2. PDF 95 KB
- NOR 3 - APPLICANT_STATEMENT_FOR_THE_LOCAL_REVIEW_BODY-3501996, item 2. PDF 498 KB
- NOR 4 - APPLICATION_FORM-3504412, item 2. PDF 4 MB
- NOR 5 - LOCATIONPLAN-3502008, item 2. PDF 733 KB
- NOR 6- SITE_PLAN-3502016, item 2. PDF 823 KB
- NOR 7 - GROUND_FLOOR_EXISTING_PLAN-3502006, item 2. PDF 561 KB
- NOR 8 - GROUND_FLOOR_PROPOSED_PLAN-3502007, item 2. PDF 756 KB
- NOR 9 - FIRST_FLOOR_PLAN_PROPOSED-3502005, item 2. PDF 815 KB
- NOR 10 - ELEVATIONS_EXISTING-3502003, item 2. PDF 2 MB
- NOR 11 - ELEVATIONS_PROPOSED-3502004, item 2. PDF 2 MB
- NOR 12 - DDL_CARE_HUB_APPLICATION_SUPPORTING_STATEMENT-3502001, item 2. PDF 121 KB
- NOR 13 - CAVALRY_PARK_LIST_OF_COMPANIES-3501999, item 2. PDF 104 KB
- NOR 14 - DDL_CARE_HUB_LTD_BUSINESS_PLAN-3502002, item 2. PDF 495 KB
- NOR 15 - SBC_PRE-APPLICATION_ADVICE-3502013, item 2. PDF 196 KB
- NOR 16 - REFUSAL_NOTICE-3502010, item 2. PDF 67 KB
- NOR 17 - REPORT_OF_HANDLING-3502011, item 2. PDF 113 KB
- NOR 18 - SBC_FORWARD_PLANNING_CONSULTATION_RESPONSE-3502012, item 2. PDF 160 KB
- NOR 19 - SBC_ROADS_CONSULTATION_RESPONSE-3502014, item 2. PDF 37 KB
- 5(c) - PRT 1 - 21_00486_FUL_-_REFUSED_DRAWINGS-3504473, item 2. PDF 925 KB
- 5(c) - PRT 2 - 05_02146_FUL_-_DECISION_NOTICE-3515159, item 2. PDF 2 MB
- 5(c) - PRT 3 - 05_02146_FUL_-_OFFICERS_REPORT-3515164, item 2. PDF 27 KB
- 5(c) - PRT 4 - 06-02165-FUL APPROVED-3212671, item 2. PDF 2 MB
- 5(c) - PRT 5 - 06_02165_FUL_-_OFFICERS_REPORT-3513529, item 2. PDF 100 KB
- 5(c) - PRT 6 - 08-01525-FUL APPROVED-2123250, item 2. PDF 2 MB
- 5(c) - PRT 7 - 08_01525_FUL_-_OFFICERS_REPORT-3513538, item 2. PDF 9 KB
- 5(c) - PRT 8 - 18-01756-FUL Decision Notice, item 2. PDF 144 KB
- 5(c) - PRT 9 - 18-01756-FUL OFFICERS_REPORT-3082246, item 2. PDF 100 KB
- 5(d) - 21_00486_FUL_-_CONSULTATION_REPLIES-3504432, item 2. PDF 275 KB
- 5(e) - List of Policies, item 2. PDF 150 KB