Agenda item
Consider request for review of refusal of application for erection of two dwellinghouses in paddock N of Station House, Cowdenburn. 20/00714/PPP. 20/00023/RREF.
Copies of the following papers attached:-
Minutes:
There had been circulated copies of the request from Mr Stuart Corrigan, per Andrew Bennie Planning Limited to review the decision to refuse the planning application for erection of two dwellinghouses in the paddock north of Station House, Cowdenburn. The supporting papers included the Notice of Review (including the Officer’s Report and Decision Notice); papers referred to in the Officer’s Report, consultations; and a list of policies. In noting the site of the proposed development, Members referred to their determination of a previous application as documented in the Notice of Review submission and which related to a site on the eastern side of the road and where they had agreed a building group was present. In this regard Members re-stated their interpretation of the boundary of that building group which, whilst noting their presence, did not include the buildings on the opposite side of the road and the site of the proposed development. After further consideration they concluded that the site was not a well related addition to the building group. They also noted that in terms of the scale of addition, there was no further capacity to extend the building group within the current Local Development Plan period.
DECISION
AGREED that:-
(a) the request for review had been competently made in terms of Section 43A of the Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997;
(b) the review could be considered without the need for any further procedure on the basis of the papers submitted;
(c) the proposal would be contrary to the Development Plan and that there were no other material considerations that would justify departure from the Development Plan; and
(d) the officer’s decision to refuse the application be upheld and the application be refused, for the reasons detailed in Appendix I to this Minute
Supporting documents:
- Item 2 - Appendix I - LRB Decision Notice - 20-00714-PPP 20-00023-RREF, item 2. PDF 120 KB
- Item 5(a) - NOR 1 - APPLICATION_PDF-3387546, item 2. PDF 606 KB
- Item 5(a) - NOR 2 - STATEMENT_IN_SUPPORT_OF_REQUEST_TO_REVIEW-3387132, item 2. PDF 141 KB
- Item 5(a) - NOR 3 - APPLICATION_FORM-3387123, item 2. PDF 548 KB
- Item 5(a) - NOR 4 - SITE_LOCATION_PLAN-3387130, item 2. PDF 122 KB
- Item 5(a) - NOR 5 - SITE_PLAN-3387131, item 2. PDF 116 KB
- Item 5(a) - NOR 6 - PLANNING_STATEMENT_IN_SUPPORT_OF_APPLICATION-3387128, item 2. PDF 128 KB
- Item 5(a) - NOR 7 - REPORT_OF_HANDLING-3387129, item 2. PDF 74 KB
- Item 5(a) - NOR 8 - DECISION_NOTICE-3387125, item 2. PDF 24 KB
- Item 5(a) - NOR 9 - LRB_DECISION-3387126, item 2. PDF 121 KB
- Item 5(b) - PRT 1 - 20_00714_PPP_-_REFUSED_DRAWINGS-3387603, item 2. PDF 450 KB
- Item 5(b) - PRT 2 - REFUSED-2136588, item 2. PDF 305 KB
- Item 5(b) - PRT 3 - SITE_LOCATION_PLAN___NEIGHBOUR_NOTIFICATION-2136590, item 2. PDF 4 MB
- Item 5(b) - PRT 4 - DECISION_NOTICE-2531281, item 2. PDF 747 KB
- Item 5(b) - PRT 5 - OFFICERS_REPORT-2531265, item 2. PDF 72 KB
- Item 5(b) - PRT 6 = LOCATION_PLAN_SHOWING_LAND_OWNERSHIP-2531282, item 2. PDF 734 KB
- Item 5(b) - PRT 7 - LRB_DECISION_NOTICE-2549356, item 2. PDF 136 KB
- Item 5(c) - 20_00714_PPP_-_CONSULTATION_REPLIES-3387604, item 2. PDF 254 KB
- Item 5(d) - List of Policies, item 2. PDF 104 KB