Agenda item
Consider request for review of refusal of application for erection of two dwellinghouses and associated works on land NW of Quarry Bank, Hume. 19/01432/PPP. 20/00009/RREF.
Copies of the following papers attached:-
Minutes:
There had been circulated copies of the request from Mr Andrew Thomson, per Ferguson Planning, 54 Island Street, Galashiels, to review refusal of the planning application for erection of two dwellinghouses and associated works on land North West of Quarry Bank, Hume. The supporting papers included the Notice of Review (including the Decision Notice and Officer’s Report); applications referred to by applicant; papers referred to in the Officer’s Report; consultations; support comments; and a list of policies. Having accepted that the village of Hume constituted a building group and that there was capacity to expand the group, Members’ discussion focussed on whether the proposed site for two houses was well related to and reflected the character of the group. They noted the linear nature of housing to the east of the site and that houses were principally on the same side of the public road as the site. Members concluded that the proposed development was an appropriate addition to the building group subject to a new planted boundary being provided to the west of the site. In their discussion they addressed concerns raised by the Roads Planning Officer about connectivity of the site to the footpath and street lighting at the eastern end of the village but noted the rural character of the settlement and that connection to these facilities may not be within the control of the applicant.
DECISION
AGREED that:-
(a) the request for a review had been competently made in terms of Section 43A of the Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997;
(b) the review could be considered without the need for any further procedure on the basis of the papers submitted;
(c) the proposal would be in keeping with the Development Plan; and
(d) the officer’s decision to refuse the application be reversed and planning permission be granted, subject to conditions, informatives and a legal agreement, for the reasons detailed in Appendix II to this Minute.
Supporting documents:
- Item 3 - Appendix ll - LRB Intentions Notice - 20-00009-RREF Hume, item 3. PDF 138 KB
- Item 6(a) - NOR 1 - NOTICE_OF_REVIEW, item 3. PDF 3 MB
- Item 6(a) - NOR 2 - LOCAL_REVIEW_STATEMENT, item 3. PDF 573 KB
- Item 6(a) - NOR 3 - LOCATION_PLAN, item 3. PDF 213 KB
- Item 6(a) - NOR 4 - EXISTING_SITE_PLAN, item 3. PDF 147 KB
- Item 6(a) - NOR 5 - PROPOSED_SITE_PLAN, item 3. PDF 2 MB
- Item 6(a) - NOR 6 -DECISION_NOTICE, item 3. PDF 115 KB
- Item 6(a) - NOR 7 - REPORT_OF_HANDLING, item 3. PDF 79 KB
- Item 6(a) - NOR 8 - APPLICATION_FORM, item 3. PDF 94 KB
- Item 6(a) - NOR 9 - PLANNING_STATEMENT, item 3. PDF 452 KB
- Item 6(b) - 15-00774-PPP DECISION_NOTICE, item 3. PDF 2 MB
- Item 6(b) - 15-00774-PPP COMMITTEE_REPORT-2707229, item 3. PDF 620 KB
- Item 6(b) - 15-00774-PPP - SITE_LAYOUT, item 3. PDF 102 KB
- Item 6(b) - 18-01228-PPP APPROVAL, item 3. PDF 282 KB
- Item 6(b) - 18-01228-PPP OFFICERS_REPORT-3048482, item 3. PDF 98 KB
- Item 6(b) - 18-01228-PPP - INDICATIVE_SITE_LAYOUT-3024756, item 3. PDF 101 KB
- Item 6(b) - 19-00280-AMC -APPROVAL, item 3. PDF 150 KB
- Item 6(b) - 19-00280-AMC - OFFICERS_REPORT, item 3. PDF 78 KB
- Item 6(b) - 19-00280-AMC_SITE_PLAN, item 3. PDF 7 MB
- Item 6(c) - PRT 1_-_REFUSED_DRAWINGS-3336548, item 3. PDF 1 MB
- Item 6(c) - PRT 2 - 08-01217-OUT REFUSED-2112097, item 3. PDF 161 KB
- Item 6(c) - PRT 3 - 08-01217-OUT COMMITTEE_REPORT-2136585, item 3. PDF 142 KB
- Item 6(c) - PRT 4 - 08-01217/OUT - DISMISSED-2162209, item 3. PDF 357 KB
- Item 6(c) - PRT 5 - 08_01217_OUT-SITE_PLAN, item 3. PDF 367 KB
- Item 6(c) - PRT 6 - 18/01145/FUL - APPROVAL-3044537, item 3. PDF 2 MB
- Item 6(c) - PRT 7 - 18/01145/FUL OFFICERS_REPORT-3044540, item 3. PDF 74 KB
- Item 6(c) - PRT 8 - 18/01145/FUL LOCATION_PLAN-3021994, item 3. PDF 3 MB
- Item 6(d) - CONSULTATIONS, item 3. PDF 536 KB
- Item 6(e)_-_SUPPORT_COMMENTS, item 3. PDF 19 KB
- Item 6(f) - List of Policies, item 3. PDF 96 KB